I'd like to echo Jason's sentiments regarding the "added value" of the fanclub.  Even multi-billionaires U2 had a very good deal with their fanclub--$20 got me four issues of the very impressively assembled Propaganda magazine, an exclusive bonus live CD, and a chance to buy advance tickets for local shows (usually slightly cheaper).  I can certainly vouch for the Crowded House/Split Enz/Neil Finn club as well--a level of personalized service that I'd have thought impossible given the high number of members...for $15/year.
 
I'm glad I held back on spending the $65 for Sting's group (and I'm certainly a bigger Sting fan than a U2 or even Neil Finn fan), but the "added value" just didn't seem worth it.  I'd love the chance to see an exclusive fanclub show in NYC, but not for an additional high ticket cost on TOP of the high fan club fee.  As for getting to buy tickets for other shows on the tour, I really don't think being in the club would give me an advantage.
 
I'm curious to know what'll be on the "exclusive" CD-ROM, and how long it'll be before that material surfaces in other formats, and whether it'll help justify the cost.
 
Sorry to those that have joined and feel disappointed.  I'm glad I saved my money for the Japanese SACD version of Sacred Love ($31.84 including shipping from www.cdjapan.co.jp).
 
-b-