[Police] Are you ever baffled...

.. when you love a police or Sting song, and just CAN'T understand why, when you play it for someone else, they don't? I remember when I was kid, and I desperately wanted my elderly neighbor to hear "Every Breath You Take." SO I basically MAKE her listen to it, and she says calmly "Yes Ross, it's a nice song." "That was it?" I thought to myself. Nice song. NICE SONG!!!!??? It's an incredible song. How CAN SHE RESIST!!!! Something I'll never understand.