The M15 cb is really very lightweight. I doubt its deployment would have helped Murray. And it is possible the board being down would help but probably more so in the case of large seas, as in my understanding, it's getting the boat up off horizontal on a steep swell that causes it to more easily trip. I'm with you on the hasp deal, and I've considered them but just neglected to do anything about the situation. Any recommendations of great, unobtrusive, locker hasps? t Tom Smith & Jane Van Winkle Sandpoint, Idaho M15-345, Chukar -----Original Message----- From: Honshells [mailto:chonshell@ia4u.net] Sent: Thursday, January 16, 2003 4:44 PM To: montgomery_boats@mailman.xmission.com Subject: M_Boats: self righting Practically every boat review I've read says boats (of all sizes) should have hasps on their cockpit lockers, a feature many manufacturers don't offer (easy enough for buyers to add their own). After reading Murray's post, I'm considering them more seriously. Would a centerboard retracted into its trunk inhibit righting? The result is less surface to brace against to right the boat, but the Montys' ballast is slung low, either way. Another question: I have been told that when conditions get dicey, I'm less likely to suffer a knock-down if the board is up. The theory is that, without the board's resistance, the boat will "skitter" sideways in a gust, rather than going over. What's the consensus? ----- Original Message ----- From: <s.mcclellan@attbi.com> To: <montgomery_boats@mailman.xmission.com> Sent: Thursday, January 16, 2003 10:38 AM Subject: self righting Murray--I agree with Rich that the details of your experience with the M-15 knock-down would be of interest to all of us. Whatever details you can provide about the events leading up to it could help us to avoid losing all the stuff in our cockpit lockers as well. One other question: did you notice-- did the centerboard swing back up into the slot when she went over? It seems likely given your description of her position in the water, and if so, then it is very possible that this contributed to the lack of self-righting, and it would behoove M15 owners to seriously consider some kind of down-position locking mechanism for the centerboard. Also, what kind of positive floatation does she carry. This was a big discussion in this group last winter. I personally have NO added floatation in my M15, but I know a lot of people do, and I am definitely planning to add some sooner or later. (Maybe a lot sooner, now that I've heard your story.) Thanks for sharing! -- Steve McClellan~~M15~#152~~Chicago _______________________________________________ http://mailman.xmission.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/montgomery_boats This message was scanned for viruses.
I don't have a recommendation for a good hasp, but I hope another reader will, Tom, thanks. --Craig ----- Original Message ----- From: "Smith, Tom" <Tom.Smith@itron.com> To: <montgomery_boats@mailman.xmission.com> Sent: Thursday, January 16, 2003 7:52 PM Subject: self righting The M15 cb is really very lightweight. I doubt its deployment would have helped Murray. And it is possible the board being down would help but probably more so in the case of large seas, as in my understanding, it's getting the boat up off horizontal on a steep swell that causes it to more easily trip. I'm with you on the hasp deal, and I've considered them but just neglected to do anything about the situation. Any recommendations of great, unobtrusive, locker hasps? t Tom Smith & Jane Van Winkle Sandpoint, Idaho M15-345, Chukar -----Original Message----- From: Honshells [mailto:chonshell@ia4u.net] Sent: Thursday, January 16, 2003 4:44 PM To: montgomery_boats@mailman.xmission.com Subject: self righting Practically every boat review I've read says boats (of all sizes) should have hasps on their cockpit lockers, a feature many manufacturers don't offer (easy enough for buyers to add their own). After reading Murray's post, I'm considering them more seriously. Would a centerboard retracted into its trunk inhibit righting? The result is less surface to brace against to right the boat, but the Montys' ballast is slung low, either way. Another question: I have been told that when conditions get dicey, I'm less likely to suffer a knock-down if the board is up. The theory is that, without the board's resistance, the boat will "skitter" sideways in a gust, rather than going over. What's the consensus? ----- Original Message ----- From: <s.mcclellan@attbi.com> To: <montgomery_boats@mailman.xmission.com> Sent: Thursday, January 16, 2003 10:38 AM Subject: self righting Murray--I agree with Rich that the details of your experience with the M-15 knock-down would be of interest to all of us. Whatever details you can provide about the events leading up to it could help us to avoid losing all the stuff in our cockpit lockers as well. One other question: did you notice-- did the centerboard swing back up into the slot when she went over? It seems likely given your description of her position in the water, and if so, then it is very possible that this contributed to the lack of self-righting, and it would behoove M15 owners to seriously consider some kind of down-position locking mechanism for the centerboard. Also, what kind of positive floatation does she carry. This was a big discussion in this group last winter. I personally have NO added floatation in my M15, but I know a lot of people do, and I am definitely planning to add some sooner or later. (Maybe a lot sooner, now that I've heard your story.) Thanks for sharing! -- Steve McClellan~~M15~#152~~Chicago
I've thought about fasteners for the lids from time to time but haven't gone beyond that - these stories, however, are getting my attention. I installed stainless steel spring loaded stops in my bimini so that I could disassemble the tubes but not have them come apart when I didn't want them to. I've seen larger versions that might do the job on the lids. Push the button in and the lid will open but it will stay shut if the button isn't depressed. They just might fit in the hollow under the rolled lip of the storage compartment. (The button has to pass through the base and the lid.) The job will require drilling through the front of the lid and the first layer of the cockpit under the closed lid - then securing the fastener through the hole from the underside. The buttons do not protrude much and wouldn't snag my hairy legs like hasps can - and except for perhaps really violent shaking while Carol II is lying on her side or turned turtle (can't believe I'm even thinking such things!) they would hold the lid shut. If it gets violent enough to shake the lid open I deserve to lose whatever was in the bin for being out in that weather. Stan M-15, #177, Carol II
participants (3)
-
Honshells -
Smith, Tom -
Stanley Winarski