Hi Paul, Just saw you post / questions (on the Potter forum) regarding the same in a P-19. I would think it prudent to compare the M-15 to the P-15. Some of us M Boat owners have owned P boats. You'll find that comparison to bring out lots of the P boats faults. Then if size is the issue, compare the M-17 to the P-19. Again, you'll find that some of us tried the P boats before graduating to the M Boats. The M Boats aren't usually a sailors first sailboat. The M Boats are purchased after being disolutioned and dissapointed with other brands. They cost more, are better built, are stronger and much faster... etc, etc. You be the judge. The best way to convince yourself of the abilities of each one is to test sail. If you are serious about buying your sailboat, put that request on the owners groups. I'll guess there are plenty of P boats in your area as well as some Montys. You'll be very glad you found out about the M Boats before you buy something you may not wish to keep. Like the Bay Area, I've read some pretty harrowing accounts of sailing in your part of the country. My advice... (for what it's worth) look closely at the seaworthiness of each craft you are considering. Remember Gilligan and crew were only going out for a two hour cruise when they found themselves shipwrecked on a lost desert Isle. Regards, Bill SF Bay M-17 #496 "Tiperary"