My son complained that his bag of m&m's contained "all browns, and no blues." His evidence being unavailable (he ate them all), and suspecting exaggeration, I bought three bags at two locations with these results Milk Chocolate M&M's 1.69oz (47.9g) bag, 240 calories Package shows all colors but brown. BAG 1 6 May 2003 10:30am - Safeway, Middlefield Road, Palo Alto 20 red 16 brown 5 orange 7 yellow 6 green 4 blue 58 Total BAG 2A 6 May 2003, 11am -- Long's Drugs, downtown Palo Alto 21 brown 12 green 11 orange 6 yellow 4 blue 3 red 57 Total BAG 2B 6 May 2003, 11am - Long's Drugs, downtown Palo Alto 20 brown 9 yellow 9 blue 9 red 7 orange 3 green 57 Total Brown does seem to be overrepresented. Statistically significant, or merely tasty? Thane Plambeck 650 321 4884 office 650 323 4928 fax http://www.qxmail.com/home.htm
I expect lots of brown M&M's - my theory of the candy is that you need a large base of browns to establish the essential nature of the chocolate experience, but the colors add a variety that can be exploited either by an extensive planning process that consumes the colors in a balanced sequence, or in which one competes with siblings for the rare colors, simultaneously belittling the intelligence of anyone who gets ahead (if someone grabs two blues, you say that blues are yucky and grab two greens, declaring them to be superior). If you select m&m's at random from the bag, how close do you expect to get to a balanced sequence? What is a balanced sequence? Intuitively, it means that any contiguous subsequence has the expected number of colors. If there are 4 blues out of 60 candies, you'd want them spaced out about 15 apart. So, I have never believed that the colors were supposed to drawn from a uniform distribution. There should be more browns. Beyond that, I've suspected that the rest were indeed drawn from a uniform distribution. I think your numbers support that, except that blues are indeed new, and are meant to incite envy. I don't know if blues were taken out of the green distribution or added as a new category. As I remember one of my favorite urn problems, if you are trying to distinguish between two possible distributions, sampling is a very accurate method. But, it you don't know anything about the distribution, then you need a lot of samples. At 240 calories per bag, maybe you don't want to know the answer. Hilarie
participants (2)
-
Thane Plambeck -
The Purple Streak, Hilarie Orman