I have a question: is there a music editing program which can clear the vocal parts from a song (and vice versa: make the instrumental parts disappear and leave an "acapella")? I'm doing a series of "bootleg" remixes for a longer mix CD, so I'd be glad to hear some answers... Thanks a Gyerek "I've been caught stealing once when I was five, I enjoy stealing, it's as simple as that" (Jane's Addiction) _________________________________________________________________ MSN 8 with e-mail virus protection service: 2 months FREE* http://join.msn.com/?page=features/virus
is there a music editing program which can clear the vocal parts from a song
No. Try getting an egg out of a cake, that's easier. ;-) (there is a basic method of channel mixing to delete large chunks of music from a track, but the results are not predictable) -------- Thomas Touzimsky My head is spinnin' so My feet don't touch the ground My eyes is blinded by the light My hearin' deafened by the sound My body's shakin' like a leaf My hearts been beatin' out of time My blood's been boilin' up inside And I've been fearin' for my life
kind of no, there are things which claim to do it, and on some tracks it works quite well but on most is pretty crap... on the behringer modulizer there is a 'voice canceller' what it does is just plays the sounds which are stereo or out of phase, so on old vocals they used chorus effects to make the vocal sound wider and a bit more solid. Everything is removed that is the same in both channels, so you end up with the reverb and delays. but the answer is mostly no! ----- Original Message ----- From: Thomas Touzimsky <thomas@klf.de> To: 'All bound for Mu-Mu Land.' <klf@mailman.xmission.com> Sent: Monday, November 10, 2003 11:52 AM Subject: AW: [KLF] OT: bootlegmixing
is there a music editing program which can clear the vocal parts from a song
No. Try getting an egg out of a cake, that's easier. ;-)
(there is a basic method of channel mixing to delete large chunks of music from a track, but the results are not predictable)
-------- Thomas Touzimsky
My head is spinnin' so My feet don't touch the ground My eyes is blinded by the light My hearin' deafened by the sound My body's shakin' like a leaf My hearts been beatin' out of time My blood's been boilin' up inside And I've been fearin' for my life
_______________________________________________ KLF mailing list KLF@mailman.xmission.com http://mailman.xmission.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/klf
Oddly there was an effect you could apply like this built into the original Sony Playstation's audio CD player. It kinda mixes out the vocals but the results are...erm...mixed. It seems to work better with some stuff than others, basically the more simple the recording and less overdubs etc the more effective it is and I would imagine it would be the same with dedicated software. With the Beatles for instance, who's stuff was mostly recorded on four-track often with a separate vocal track it is fairly easy to almost completely isolate or remove the vocals (I have seen a few dodgy bootlegs where this has been done and they are listed as alternate takes or demos). More contemporary music recorded on 48 track or whatever is harder to break down, though applying similar methods can result in some interesting effects, or just a kinda muffled hollow noise (on the PS at least). I'd imagine you could use some software to remove certain frequencies but this is likely to still affect both vocals and music. There is a site dedicated to accapellas, I forget the address but you can access it via http://www.boomselection.net which is a pretty tidy site in itself. Alternatively, try searching 'accapella' with any decent file-sharing client and you should return dozens of interesting vocal tracks. Also try searching 'instrumental' along with the band of your choice. Thomas Touzimsky <thomas@klf.de> wrote:
is there a music editing program which can clear the vocal parts from a song
No. Try getting an egg out of a cake, that's easier. ;-) (there is a basic method of channel mixing to delete large chunks of music from a track, but the results are not predictable) -------- Thomas Touzimsky My head is spinnin' so My feet don't touch the ground My eyes is blinded by the light My hearin' deafened by the sound My body's shakin' like a leaf My hearts been beatin' out of time My blood's been boilin' up inside And I've been fearin' for my life _______________________________________________ KLF mailing list KLF@mailman.xmission.com http://mailman.xmission.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/klf --------------------------------- Do you Yahoo!? Protect your identity with Yahoo! Mail AddressGuard
participants (4)
-
Jon Doe -
KLF- gyerek -
Simon Glass -
Thomas Touzimsky