A Note on Real vs Complex Fields
In reply to the member who seemed upset about my comments about the complex multiplication not reducing to real operations, I have to say a few things. 1. There's no room for indicating that a member is old-fashioned in my opinion. In any case, I won't waste time replying to such a person in the future after two occurrences of that behavior. 2. A positive or neutral orientation is the most easily detected part of reading somebody's internet or email postings, and I don't reply to people with negative orientations after two occurrences of that behavior. 3. The real and complex fields are NOT ISOMORPHIC, and the two- dimensional Euclidean plane regarded as a vector space R2 over the real field is not algebraically isomorphic to the complex plane over the complex field because R2 has no complex multiplication. This is not old-fashioned - it is upper division algebra. 4. The positive part of what I said in my previous posting is the part that is obscured by readers' anger: Rare Event Theory is the only way that I know of to get partially around the difficulty of item 3. Osher Doctorow
OSHER DOCTOROW wrote:
3. The real and complex fields are NOT ISOMORPHIC, and the two- dimensional Euclidean plane regarded as a vector space R2 over the real field is not algebraically isomorphic to the complex plane over the complex field because R2 has no complex multiplication. This is not old-fashioned - it is upper division algebra.
It's also no surprise to me - of course they're not isomorphic; I certainly didn't say they were, unless it was through misinterpreting something you said. Oops, that's three negative statements.
4. The positive part of what I said in my previous posting is the part that is obscured by readers' anger: Rare Event Theory is the only way that I know of to get partially around the difficulty of item 3.
Perhaps if you were to say what this "difficulty" you keep alluding to is... Morgan L. Owens "My, aren't we feeling sensitive?"
participants (2)
-
MARLENE DOCTOROW -
Morgan L. Owens